Comparison and Contrast: Parliamentary vs. Presidential Systems
Comparative Government and Politics
- Translate
Index
Advertisement
Parliamentary System
- Fusion of Powers: The executive and legislative branches are intertwined. The Prime Minister, the head of government, is typically a member of the legislature.
- Collective Responsibility: The government is collectively responsible to the legislature. If the government loses the confidence of the legislature, it must resign.
- No Fixed Term: The government serves until it loses the confidence of the legislature or until a general election is called.
- Examples: United Kingdom, Canada, India, Australia
Presidential System
- Separation of Powers: The executive, legislative, and judicial branches are separate and have distinct powers.
- Fixed Terms: The president, as the head of state and government, serves a fixed term, regardless of the performance of the administration.
- Checks and Balances: The system includes checks and balances to prevent any one branch from becoming too powerful.
Examples: United States, Brazil, Mexico, Nigeria
Key Differences and Characteristics
Feature | Parliamentary System | Presidential System |
Formation of Government | Formed by the party or coalition with a majority in the legislature. | Elected directly by the people. |
Accountability | Directly accountable to the legislature. | Directly accountable to the people. |
Stability | Can be more prone to instability due to coalition governments or frequent elections. | Tends to be more stable due to fixed terms. |
Flexibility | More flexible, as the government can be replaced without a general election. | Less flexible, as the president serves a fixed term. |
Advertisement
Conclusion :
Both parliamentary and presidential systems have their own advantages and disadvantages. The choice of system depends on a country's political culture, historical context, and specific needs. For example, parliamentary systems may be more suitable for countries with strong political parties and a consensus-based culture, while presidential systems may be more suitable for countries with a diverse political landscape and a need for stability.
Advertisement
Share
Other Topics
Unit - II
Advertisement
Back to
Advertisement